File a Claim
At Benson Davis, we pride ourselves on our customer service and our preference is for you to contact us to report a claim. If you need to report a claim immediately after hours or during a holiday or weekend, you may use the links below to contact your insurance company directly. Or feel free to contact us in an emergency, via our cell phones: Matt Banazek cell phone (607) 345-7369 | Lee Benson cell phone (607) 345-3950
 Click image to file claim online.
Central Co-operative Insurance Company
Claims Office (24/7): 1-800-367-3743 Auto Glass Claim: 1-800-552-3743 |
 Click image to file claim online
Chautauqua Patrons
Claims Office: 1-800-896-4720 |
 Click image to file claim online
Countryway Insurance Claims Phone Number:
M-F: 8:00AM-4:30PM EST: 1-800-828-6862 After Hours Claim Center: 1-888-223-3649 |
 Click image to file claim online
Dryden Mutual Insurance
Claims Office (Office Hours): 1-800-782-0154 (After Hours) 1-800-556-5802 or 1-607-428-0176 |
 Click image to file claim online
Erie Insurance Group
Claims Office (24/7): 1-800-367-3743 Auto Glass Claim: 1-800-552-3743 |
 Click image to file claim online
Madison Mutual
Claims Office: (315) 687-321 |
 Click image to file claim online
Main Street America Group
Claims Office (24/7): 1-877-425-2467 |
 Click image to file claim online
National General
Claims Office: 1-800-325-1088 |
 Click image to file claim online
Ontario Insurance
Main Office : 585-289-9560 |
 Click image to file claim online
Preferred Mutual
Claims Phone Number: 1-800-333-7642 option #4 Auto Glass/Windshield Number: 1-800-333-7642 option #8 |
 Click image to file claim online
Progressive Insurance
Claims Office (24/7): 1-800-Progressive |